Pink Floyd: ‘Dogs’ (2018) | Is it any Good?

The bass guitar is a smidge on the light side I feel.
Have you reviewed the whole album remix? Some weird drums on Sheep

i think this new mix is outstanding. I would have liked an emersive box set as well, but a terrific sounding remix nonetheless.

you summed it up at the start of this yea witch ones piknk

Waters' bass is iconic. Pink Floyd is one of the few bands where I actually notice the bass guitar

Somewhat ironically: I was in college back when "Animals" was released, and at the time there were many of my friends who considered it a welcome "return to form" after the somewhat weaker album of "Wish You Were Here". But as time went on, people's opinions of "Wish You Were Here" kept going higher, while "Animals" seemed less wonderful. I was friends with the owner of a local record store (back when "local record stores" still existed…), and in the early 90's he said that for his stores the catalog-sales of "Animals" was the lowest of all Pink Floyd albums. (by the late 1990's that position was taken over by the lower catalog-sales for "The Final Cut" ).
I think "Animals" was tied a bit too much to the time it was released, especially with the song "Pigs, Three Different Ones". I suspect that most fans of Pink Floyd music who were born after 1980 don't even know the three specific people which are referenced in that song.
Personally, I think the two "Pigs on the Wing" songs and "Dogs" are among the best songs that PF has done. However, I don't care much for the other songs on the album, although I did really like "Pigs, Three Different Ones" back when it was first released.

This mix just confirms what the AMLOR remix already made apparent: Gilmour (though I love the guy) didn't realize how valuable Wright was until much letter than he lets on. At the time of Animals, there was a "clear hierarchy" (his words, not mine), and it definitely shows here. Some beautiful Rhodes parts make their first appearance, and all Wright's atmosphere work had been toned down on the original, and are now allowed to properly shine, almost to the point of changing the song's mood as you say. The central solo, which was an atmospheric weak point to me, is now on par with the rest of the song, which makes it pretty much perfect now. Good thing for Nick that his complexity can be heard again. Overall an amazing new mix.

It’s a great remix!!

"Dogs" to me is one of Floyd's best songs & so many people have never heard it. What a shame

Short answer brilliant

The mix is not bad… although by putting some of the 'ingredients' to the foreground… it will be at the cost of some other 'ingredients' I think.

Does Waters use leftist politics to numb guilt about Syd?
Roger said he laughed at Syds "crazy idea" to bring in 2 females to sing/play saxaphone before kicking him out then a female singer and a saxaphone are put on Darkside not to mention a rerecording of Syds Clockwork Room at end of Bike for opening of Time and Roger also reused Syds "scribbly black" line in it too.

And if you buy either the Blu-ray or the box set you will get the remix AND the original mix included as well as the 5.1.

I don't understand the idea behind this remix. Everything is disconnected. More clarity? I mean is it really all about technological aspects? Because I can assure you that it is all there on original mix.

Oh, you have now less money because you bought it. Oh, I'm sorry.

In my opinion, remix isn't worth any kind of attention. And I'm really worried that Pink Floyd (after the beatles) is doing that.

How have you all heard this? Not released yet

Have you been dipping your chin into a bowl of tippex again?

Il give myself a full review during my next LSD trip listening