The obsession that bent a generation
Start your day smarter – join over 4 million professionals reading Morning Brew for free by clicking https://morningbrew.yt.link/JyZc5rl
More info and sources at bottom.
Find me elsewhere:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/philedwardsinc/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/philedwardsinc
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/philedwardsinc
Some music by the inimitable Tom Fox via Chromatic: https://tfbeats.com/
Where I get some music (Free trial affiliate link):
https://share.epidemicsound.com/olkrqv
My camera, as of February 2022 (affiliate link):
https://amzn.to/3HDcWVz
My main lens: https://amzn.to/3IteXEK
My main light: https://amzn.to/3pjO0M8
My main light accessory: https://amzn.to/3M6eL0j
Sources: https://www.patreon.com/posts/140995396/
The strange history of good posture runs deeper than straight backs and gym class. In this video, Phil Edwards uncovers America’s posture panic—a century-long obsession with standing up straight that mixed pseudoscience, scandal, and social control. From William H. Sheldon’s “Atlas of Men”, which classified people by body type, to nude posture photos at Harvard, Wellesley, and Yale, this story reveals how ideas about fitness, psychology, and morality became entangled. Featuring insights from historian Beth Linker, author of Slouch: Posture Panic and the Making of American Posture in Modern America, the film explores how “good posture” became a moral standard rather than a medical fact.
Through archival images, plumb-line diagrams, and American Posture League propaganda, we trace how early 20th-century reformers measured, photographed, and graded students on posture. Industrial logic and the rise of machines shaped how Americans thought about their bodies—standing tall meant efficiency, discipline, and virtue. As college enrollment surged, mandatory posture exams and “perfect body” campaigns normalized invasive measurement and moral judgment. What started as health science turned into an American social experiment, complete with “question mark” and “exclamation point” body charts and Wellesley’s thoracimeter posture-measuring device.
This video examines how Darwinian evolution, phrenology, and somatotypes fused into a cultural mania for straight spines and moral uprightness. It exposes how Sheldon’s somatotype theory, posture pageants, and even chiropractic contests blurred science and spectacle. The modern legacy of posture correction—ergonomic chairs, yoga, “tech neck” fears—echoes the same anxieties. Watch to learn how posture became a symbol of virtue, why Sheldon’s coin-collector mindset shaped modern grading systems, and what our obsession with perfect alignment really says about body image, conformity, and control.
@kagemushi
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
This is tangentially related, but when I moved to Japan I noticed a lot of women who stood and walked with pronounced pigeon toed gaits. I later dated a Japanese woman who told me many girls would be trained that way by their mothers because it makes them look more innocent and "feminine". It's something about it being associated with how courtesans walked with geta sandals in previous time periods. It's an anecdotal explanation, but it's interesting to think about in relation to the posture panic.
@NewRealizm
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
funny how the body positivity just vanished with one little prick – ozempic 🙂
@NewRealizm
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
crazy how we reverted back to selfcencoring
@misioum4465
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
The youngest generation Alpha with their screen addiction cause by the lockdown in their youngest years where they were supposed to be active running and developing their bodies, most spent it bent over staring at a screen. Parents are largely oblivious, staring at their own scteens.
In later life many will pay the most severe price with neck pain and back pain , slipped discs among other.
I have concern for the suffering that lies ahead for many.
@GradyHouger
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
Improve your social status with this one neat trick!
@stevetb7777
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
It's unfortunate that this "science" of posture got off to a rocky start and was apparently abused (very interesting, thanks for the video!), THAT SAID.
It is a BIG DEAL. Your internal organs were meant to operate within a space that they do not have with poor posture, compression happens and organ function is compromised. Many systems are compromised with poor posture. The body is inhibited. This is kind of obvious. Proper posture leads to BETTER EMOTIONS, feelings of well-being, increased mobility and athleticism are possible. Proper posture makes the body MUCH less prone to injury. It DOES mean a MUCH MORE "pain free" life.
She said: "if we think it's gonna be the cure-all fix for some kind of pain free life I think the evidence is very thin to non-existent on that"
This is where I argue the most. It kind of IS.
The important distinction about posture that must be made but never really is made:
Posture is how your body holds itself when you are not doing anything.
It really isn't about posture, it's about musculoskeletal alignment.
The correction activity is all about retraining the muscles of the body to do their proper jobs.
Poor alignment means they've atrophied, forgotten how to do their proper jobs, and smaller muscle groups are compensating for larger ones.
This creates a domino effect throughout the body, as it compensates to keep the body able to move upright against gravity.
Bones get pulled out of their proper location when this happens.
When the muscles are doing their jobs properly, you have alignment, you have "naturally" good posture.
If you have to manually think about how you are sitting or standing. If you have to manually straighten yourself as was taught in days past, you are out of alignment. True posture is again about what your body does automatically.
For more information:
PAIN FREE by Pete Egoscue
or the Egoscue Method of Health Through Motion
I'm close to becoming an Egoscue certified postural alignment specialist.
WIthout his method I would have had many, many surgeries in my teenage years.
I have lead a pain free life because of postural alignment.
There's simply more to the story.
Get off your butts and correct your posture through proper exercise (like the Egoscue Method).
Your body will thank you!
(And well, yes.. you WILL look more attractive, but to me that's the least important benefit!)
AND WE SHOULD BE PANICKING – Have you seen today's youth? They are more out of alignment and musculoskeletally dysfunctional than any previous generation. Cell phones pulling their heads down and forward, playing on tablets instead of running/biking playing with friends. This is an epidemic, you shall see. These kids are going to run into massive pain and injury much earlier in life than previous generations. The day I dropped my g/f's kid at his first day of high school I watched hundreds of kids walk through those gates. Not a single one of them had good posture / alignment. Some even had conditions that were in the past more attributed to the elderly. This is a BIG DEAL.
@ROLtheWolf
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
While any moral or intellectual suppositions from posture are absurd, of course, BUT the plumb-line posture is the best way to avoid joint and back pain. Our bodies are designed to be held certain ways comfortably. Slouching can be judged to likely cause chronic problems, but is not a judge of your character.
@shadowofthecandle
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
Answer in Progress also did a great video about posture!
@RichardBaran
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
Creepers
@RichardBaran
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
"biotypeing" sounds an awful lot like eugenics
My bad it's just about getting nudes
@laurasell2353
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
I remember sitting in the lunchroom at school in 2nd grade, and slouching. I'd "catch" myself and sit up straight, like my mom would tell me. It felt like a moral failure when I kept slouching.
@claudia.ox7
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
You deserve sooooo many more subs! I randomly found your British Accents video and have then gone on to watch your other vids and they’re sooooo well planned out, and acted upon! You have a new sub from the UK 🤣
@Dearthvader2
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
ONLY LAZY BRAINWASHED FEMINISTS READ MAGAZINES.
@codiserville593
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
Read William A Rossi's article "Why Shoes Make Normal Gait Impossible" and see how the heel lift of shoes affects your joints and. … Posture
@matthewleonmartin
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
0:54 that guy's posture is bad lol
@juanpabloamorochod.752
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
Just came across you today with the british dialect video. Johnny Harris, Christopher, How Town and you have such a similar aesthics to your video, but you all worked at Vox. I tell you, Vox alumni is so good.
@Cliporado
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
I feel like being obsessed about my posture actually caused issues. My natural posture is… acceptable.
I do think SOME people have poor posture and it can add to pre-existing problems, but compared to other things (like carpal tunnel) it’s whatever
Posture in terms of social norms, I get it and have no problem perpetuating it. But, it is a certain level of toxicity to imply bad posture is universally unhealthy. You don’t need your back straight at all times 😂
@GarrettWease
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
Those craft shots rock
@metropolis10
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
First I want to say all science is invented, it starts with a question, or idea. The difference between good science and bad is do you change your mind or throw out your idea if after following the scientific method you find out it was shit. Or maybe you didn't have the right tools, and you find out something that used to be true, is now false. Or different. You have to adapt. It doesn't sound like people adapted, and it certainly doesn't sound rigorous (aside from the wankers pushing it without good evidence), and it sounds like it took us too long to adapt. So believe in science, but also recognize its limitations, especially when wielded by people. I'd be interested to know how much posture factors into physiotherapy (that works) and long term pain problems.
@Bvrlylovesscience
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
This is interesting.
Who else just adjusted their posture after watching this?
@505Daniel
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
I have Scheuermann's Kyphosis, or Scheuermann's disease, and have had countless people in my life criticize my posture, meanwhile my discs have all eroded under pressure, and I'm left with these bony nodules that cause intense pain, I have 6 compression fractures in my vertebrae leaving me with the sort of fiery pain people call into work for, but no, yeah, if I just tried to stand a little straighter…. it's all my lazy ass fault, not the literal shape of my bones.
@pegendary
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
I spent half of my teenage years being scolded for not sitting up straight, until I was finally taken to the doctor and diagnosed with severe scoliosis. I'm post spinal fusion these days, but I still have some of that rib hump, and the paranoia about looking like I'm slouched over persists to this day.
@SnapshotOfASoul
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
This is a thing so many films being set in this era get wrong, just like everyone's teeth being perfectly white (which is an invention of the 50s)… the actors don't do the "posture stance" at all anymore. It's noticeable versus real footage, which (as this video shows) has people doing that little affect where they line themselves up as they straighten up from, say, a chair. A person's posture even denoted social class, but I see so many movies and TV shows just utterly ignore this in favour of the modern, relaxed, natural posture we've had for most of human history. It's why a lot of older films also seem very wooden to us, because the actors are intentionally keeping their spines straight.
@forthrightgambitia1032
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
It reminds me of people who are convinced Diet Coke is as calorific as real coke or that breakfast is "the most important meal of the day" – pseudoscientific ideas that act as a kind of virtue signal or substitute.
@BronyOperaGhost
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
I would not survive in the posture panic
@Yourmission9
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
He really missed an opportunity to change the title of his book from “Atlas of Men” to “Atlas Shrugged”. I’ll see myself out
@enriquepadilla4154
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
My dad was raised in the 60’s and 70’s, and he always had a weird obsession with posture when i was a child, even yelling at me or hitting me when he saw me slouching, i now understand where these view came from
@izaactheberean6860
August 3, 2026 at 5:56 pm
Sheldon & others sound like perverts.
Comments are closed.