The 2005 Radio Scandal Was a Glorious Mess

A little-remembered scandal back in ’04-’05 gave a revealing and hilarious look into music industry corruption. Dozens of popular bands, from Pearl Jam to Norah Jones, relied on a playbook of unscrupulous tactics in order to get their songs played on the radio. “Gifted” playstations, six-figure payola schemes, hiring college kids to make phony song requests: These were among the tricks employed just to stay on the Billboard chart an extra week.
The 2005 radio payola scandal is a disturbing reminder how much the mainstream music market was, and continues to be, fixed. It’s also, in retrospect, really, really entertaining.
Animated by PartyKaleta:
https://www.instagram.com/partykaleta/
https://www.partykaleta.com/
More videos, cool music stories and lesser-known bands on Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/bandsplaining
(It’s just $2 — go for it!)
Songs heard in this video:
0:00 NoMBe – Zodiac Structures
0:10 Baha Men – Who Let The Dogs Out
0:18 Baha Men – Move It Like This
0:57 Pat Green – Guy Like Me
1:02 Audioslave – Light My Way
1:10 Norah Jones – Don’t Know Why
1:18 311 – Lovesong
1:24 Silent Partner – Heated Seat
1:58 Linkin Park – Points of Authority
2:33 The Mini Vandals – The Shepherd
3:05 Silent Parker – Smoke
4:40 Kevin Macleod – Bass Walker
6:37 Toby Lightman – Devils and Angels
6:56 Jewel – You Were Meant For Me
7:10 Kwon – Beatbox Lighter
7:58 Franz Ferdinand – Take Me Out
8:15 Pillar – Bring Me Down
8:20 Dream – Crazy
8:50 Blur – Crazy Beat
9:05 Pearl Jam – Get Right
10:48 Gorillaz – 19-2000
10:55 Skye Sweetman – Tangled Up In Me
11:06 New Found Glory – My Friends Over You
11:21 N.E.R.D. – Maybe
11:34 Good Charlotte – Young and Hopeless
12:46 DMX – Where The Hood At
13:23 Ashanti – Rain On Me
13:28 Norah Jones – Don’t Know Why
13:32 Ludacris – Stand Up
13:37 Brie Larson – She Said
14:38 Evelyn Thomas – High Energy
14:52 Get Set Go – Break Your Heart
16:28 The Who – Baba O’Reilly (Live at 9/11 Memorial Concert)
17:25 Engine Summer – The Sticks
@funnyyellowdog8833
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
None of that surprised me even a little bit…
1000th comment btw!
@ICRA95
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
i didnt know it was ilegal xd
@jetcheneau5811
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Move It Like This sucked fr
@themoon7435
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Anyone know the piece of music at 9:50? I don't think its on his list
@adammarsh956
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Thank you for exposing this
@allyoucaneat1234
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
when i was young, lady gaga and beyonce were constantly on LA radio stations. i remember thinking most of the songs were just bland and bad and didnt understand why they were played so much. i thought i was the crazy one who didn't understand pop culture o_O
@heggy_69
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
I was so glad when this came out because I always HATED good Charlotte
@eclat4641
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
I have imagined radio stations being held at gunpoint- and have questioned who actually likes some of the stuff they play.
@ActOneBSM
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Nothing changed. Plenty money is spent to have songs featured in spotify playlists etc
@F-Los
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Thank goodness that's all over with now.
#phew
@BobHenderson-dr2wy
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Pretty sure this has been the way it is since Casey Kasem's top 40 charts. There was only three radio stations when I was younger and all you had was classic country, rock music, and what was supposed to be modern "youth" music, and all three of them played the same 20 songs over and over again. Hell, I didn't even know genre of music existed until the dial up modem days when non-radio music started coming through the phone line.
@davedave9924
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
I sense Chicago origins
@doctordanger4143
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
I listen to Rock 107 all the time.
@DrBadtouchSaysDance
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
GASP! Payola in radio? Say it aint so
@jilliansmaniotto2326
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
finding out that good charlotte had an insane payola scheme behind them makes middle school/high school age me who hated them feel quite vindicated.
@GoodMenstruationAttitude
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
One important detail I feel gets overlooked a lot is why payola is illegal – taxpayers sold those airwaves to various companies because there weren't enough frequencies for everyone to share. Payola makes it too obvious that we MASSIVELY shortchanged ourselves in those sales, and on top of that the tradeoff in radio has not been at all useful to society (unless you count :"national security" i.e., not letting risky ideas like "socialism" creep onto mass media as worth it)
@samalexander8574
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Who narrarated this? I recognize the voice but can't place it.
@rictorn0
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Since radio these days are owned by a few corporations, its a lot easier to play the same exact song.. Every hour. Every day. But they have TONS of music in their playlist. lol. Thank god for streaming services. (Not spotify though)
@JudgedMentalMusic
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Doesn’t seem like it should be illegal
@Thatguy2youtube
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
It's a good day to be a metalhead
@katoffeevhs9798
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
ive understood for decades that commercial music is separate from normal music.
@Ciscokidcapo
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
Ain't it funny that emi even tried to pay for "19-2000" to get played and that's still like the absolute worst selling single for Gorillaz is insane
@QueMusiQ
October 14, 2024 at 2:02 pm
This isn’t going anywhere. Real rap will never get played, pop rap will. But it’s not radio, it’s streams. The haves and the have nots is defined by way of exclusive access to this sort of general exposure. So for every real rapper like Cordae or Kota you have a thousand yachties dressed like a Gyal dem Yardie. That’s not real. The labels designed it that way for mass production. Recycled almost algorithm-generated beats engineered to sound exactly like whatever FL Studio based “rap” track that is almost uniformly similar to every hit from every region of the country and the western world writ large. And to those who aren’t into mixing/mastering/production/writing, you too can pay 5-10 grand to have all the things you’d need to be exactly like them in a month. Lo key bundled and sold as a “studio in a box”, come back to YouTube and look up “type beat” to pull up tutorials on how to make a “So-and-So Type Beat”.
The software can algorithmically change the note sequence without the human input from an actual artist. It can switch up the drums somewhat so as not to just be a 1 to 1. Yes. Today, you TOO can be Metro Boomin. Right now. You can load up a ton of his songs too, feed it into a program called “NEUTRON” to train its AI on how they are mixed, apply it to YOUR beat or full song to craft a sonic blend that would fit with the songs you trained it on. Seriously, that fast. Same with Mastering, just with the software Ozone 12 made by the same company. Or just use a web application like LandR.
If you had 10k and a weekend, you too can train your COMPUTER to spit out serviceable tracks. Many will throw shade like I’m lying, just google it. It’s possible.
As for learning to rap like these pop rappers, it’s even easier. All you need is some glue and a hammer. Eat the glue and bust yaself upside the head repeatedly. Now freestyle. As your brain swells and you suffer a stroke, you halfway there!